"MEA CULPA PODCAST: MY CONVERSATION WITH TARA SETMAYER"

It's high time the Democratic leadership wake up and fight like they want to win.

Today, the United States is navigating a perfect storm of political, economic, and social crises, each exposing deep fissures in governance, civil liberties, and the fabric of democracy. At the center of this maelstrom is a potential government shutdown, looming as House Republicans push a contentious six-month funding bill laden with $14 billion in cuts to the IRS and $20 billion slashed from climate programs; a move critics argue is less about fiscal responsibility and more about appeasing the far-right Freedom Caucus. This stopgap measure, while avoiding immediate shutdown, risks alienating moderate Republicans and Democrats, leaving federal workers in swing states like Pennsylvania and Michigan vulnerable to furloughs and economic uncertainty.

Meanwhile, ICE’s mass deportation machinery grinds forward, targeting a daily arrest quota of 1,875 individuals; a 400% increase over current arrest rates, despite logistical nightmares and legal challenges. Plans to expand detention capacity to 100,000 beds using private contractors and military bases such as Fort Bliss underscore the administration’s militarized approach to immigration enforcement. Yet, with only 40% of recent arrestees having criminal records, critics argue this is less about public safety and more about political theater. The administration’s reliance on private prisons and Guantanamo Bay expansions raises ethical and legal questions, while its focus on militarizing the border ignores systemic issues driving migration.

Economic contradictions further complicate the narrative. The GOP claims Trump has brought in trillions and trillions of foreign dollar investments to restart manufacturing, but the Bureau of Economic Analysis reports less than $500 billion in actual capital expenditures. Meanwhile, the cost of living continues to rise: gasoline prices have increased by 5%, grocery costs have climbed 15%, and the price of goods has increased significantly since Trump’s re-election and tariff war. These escalating expenses starkly contrast with the administration’s claims of economic success, fueling public distrust and pessimism.

The administration’s erratic tariff policies exacerbate economic instability. Trump’s recent threat to impose a 25% tariff on Mexican imports was walked back within 48 hours, creating uncertainty for businesses that rely on cross-border trade, particularly in states like Texas and Arizona. This inconsistency undermines economic stability and highlights the administration’s lack of a coherent trade strategy.

Simultaneously, the White House perpetuates debunked claims about fentanyl smuggling, asserting that the northern border is the primary source of the drug. Customs and Border Protection data, however, shows that 90% of fentanyl seizures occur at legal ports of entry, primarily from U.S. citizens. This false narrative not only distracts from systemic drug trafficking networks but also fuels xenophobia and justifies militarized border policies.

Trump’s war on institutions escalates, with universities like Columbia facing $400 million in funding cuts over protest policies; a move critics argue contradicts First Amendment principles. His proposed executive order to strip federal funding from schools that allow “illegal protests” raises questions about the administration’s commitment to free speech and academic freedom.

Meanwhile, the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) slashes 70% of jobs at agencies like the EPA and the Department of Education, replacing career experts with political loyalists. This politicization of federal agencies undermines their ability to deliver essential services, from environmental protection to student loan oversight.

Project 2025; a Heritage Foundation blueprint for the second Trump term, seeks to codify these authoritarian shifts, empowering ICE to conduct raids in schools and hospitals and places of worship, is designed to fast-track deportations without due process. This plan starkly contrasts with America’s founding values and raises alarms about the future of democracy.

To help break all this chaos down, I welcome

Tara Setmayer

, co-founder of The Seneca Project, a bipartisan initiative mobilizing voters against extremist agendas, and a former GOP communications director turned democracy advocate. A Harvard Institute of Politics Fellow and Emmy-nominated PBS documentary narrator (Dismantling Democracy), Setmayer combines policy expertise with unflinching analysis. Her career spans Capitol Hill, where she championed immigration reform under George W. Bush, to co-founding a faith-based homeless program in Florida.

Once a staunch Republican, Setmayer left the party in 2020, becoming a senior advisor to The Lincoln Project and a vocal critic of Trump’s authoritarianism. Her work has been featured in The Daily Beast, Cosmopolitan, and MSNBC, where she dissects GOP hypocrisy and defends democratic norms. As a CNN/ABC News political commentator and 2016 “Top 20 Election Coverage Star,” she bridges grassroots activism and national discourse, offering a rare blend of pragmatism and principle.

So, let’s go now to that conversation:

And now for today’s Mea Culpa:

A growing wave of political “buyer’s remorse” is reshaping the U.S. electorate as voters who supported Donald Trump in 2024 confront the stark realities of his second-term agenda. Polls and focus groups reveal disillusionment among key demographics, including working-class and rural voters, who backed Trump primarily on economic promises that have since faltered. Gasoline prices have increased by 5%, grocery costs have risen 15%, and everyday goods remain prohibitively expensive, far from the “economic revival” Trump pledged during the campaign.

This disconnect between rhetoric and results has eroded trust, with even staunch MAGA supporters expressing frustration over chaotic governance, mass deportations, and sweeping federal job cuts. For Democrats, capitalizing on this regret ahead of the 2026 midterms requires a strategic pivot to rebuild bridges with disaffected communities.

Trump’s 2024 coalition leaned heavily on voters frustrated by inflation and Biden-era economic policies. However, his administration’s focus on culture-war issues; such as ICE’s militarized deportation quotas and threats to defund universities, has overshadowed tangible economic relief. Rural voters, in particular, feel abandoned as hospital closures, Medicaid rollbacks, and shrinking access to healthcare providers compound financial strain.

Meanwhile, Trump’s erratic tariff threats against trading partners like Canada, Mexico and China have destabilized industries reliant on cross-border commerce, further alienating moderates. These policy failures are magnified by Trump’s declining popularity: Quinnipiac polls show Republican favorability for Trump’s economic policies are at record lows.

Democrats, however, face internal divisions that threaten their ability to seize this moment. Progressive factions push for bold populist policies, while centrists argue for pragmatic solutions to broaden appeal. The party’s reliance on anti-Trump messaging has also lost potency, as seen in 2024, when the “resistance” coalition failed to secure a majority.

Rebuilding trust requires more than opposition; it demands a coherent vision that addresses working-class anxieties without alienating the progressive base. To reconnect with disillusioned voters, Democrats must prioritize economic clarity over culture wars. Highlighting Trump’s broken promises, rising costs, manufacturing shortfalls, and rural healthcare crises will resonate with those feeling betrayed; including those who supported Trump in 2024.

Emphasizing bipartisan solutions, such as protecting Social Security and expanding Medicaid in red states, would appeal to ticket-splitters who are wary of partisan extremism.

Hyper-local messaging is another critical strategy. The DNC’s rural strategy, focused on recruiting local candidates to explain policy impacts, is a start. Pairing this with tangible federal investments; such as rural broadband expansion, farm subsidies, and infrastructure projects would counter Trump’s empty slogans and demonstrate a commitment to improving lives in neglected communities.

Moreover, Democrats must differentiate themselves from MAGA extremism by amplifying contrasts between Trump’s authoritarian leanings and their own efforts to safeguard democracy and civil liberties. For example, highlighting Project 2025’s plans to raid hospitals for deportations or fast-track removals without due process can underscore the stakes of the 2026 mid-term elections.

Finally, uniting the Democratic coalition is essential. While 45% of Democrats favor centrism, 51% still support progressive policies. A platform blending populist economic measures; such as drug price caps and higher minimum wages, with moderate cultural stances would help stabilize the base while attracting independents.

Trump’s weakening support offers Democrats an opening, but success hinges on disciplined messaging and policy coherence. By addressing economic grievances directly, reengaging rural communities, and offering a credible alternative to MAGA chaos, Democrats can position themselves to reclaim Congress in 2026.

Failure to act risks ceding disillusioned voters to apathy, or worse, to a resurgent Trumpist GOP. As Rep. Ro Khanna warned, the choice is between tactical opposition and transformational change. The moment for half-measures has passed.

And as always, thanks for listening.

(Kindly consider supporting this platform and all independent journalists here on Substack. Plus, the first 240 Founding Members to this platform receive a rare, signed, numbered edition of my NYT Bestseller “Revenge, How Donald Trump weaponized The US Department Of Justice Against His Critics.” Join now!)